The Federal Communications Commission has taken the first formal
steps towards tougher rules for broadband.
It asked for public
comment on three different plans, igniting an expensive lobbying
campaign by all sides.
The looming battle follows a court ruling
questioning the FCC's right to regulate internet service providers after
one throttled traffic to users.
That court ruling
dealt a major blow to a central plank of the FCC's broadband plan called
net neutrality which demands that all data traffic be treated equally.
The
five commissioners on the FCC board were split 3-2 in putting out for
public comment proposals on new regulations for the broadband industry.
'Third
way'
One of the three plans the public is being asked to
comment on, and which is favoured by FCC chairman Julius Genachowski, is
called the "third way".
This would involve reclassifying
broadband so it went from being a lightly regulated service to one with
more vigorous oversight.
In return for this tightening up, Mr Genachowski has proposed the new
classification would not regulate on how much people pay for their
broadband. It would also shy away from overseeing internet content,
services, applications or electronic commerce sites.
The other
two options include leaving the existing regulatory framework in place
or imposing the full force of stricter regulations.
ISPs, such as
Comcast, AT&T and Verizon, prefer the status quo and have come out
against the "third way" proposal.
"This is impossible to justify
on either a policy or legal basis and we remain confident that if the
FCC persists in its course - and we truly hope it does not - the courts
will surely overturn their action," said Jim Cicconi, AT&T's senior
executive vice president for external and legislative affairs.
Verizon
said the FCC's move was "a terrible idea".
By contrast, web
giants such as Google and Amazon extol the value of free-flowing web
traffic and an open internet.
"Broadband infrastructure is too
important to be left outside of any oversight," said Richard Whitt,
Google's telecom and media counsel in a blog posting.
'To the
death'
The political dynamics of the FCC board, two
Republicans and three Democrats, imply that the "third way" looks almost
certain to be the plan it adopts.
Some suspect this will provoke
more lobbying and may draw legal challenges.
"There is a very
big fight brewing and it's the carriers versus everybody else," said
Erik Sherman, analyst with BNET.com, part of CBS's digital business
network.
"There is little doubt it's going to be a right data Donnybrook and I
am not sure the consumers are winners in any circumstances. These
companies are not fighting for the little guy. They are fighting for
themselves and higher profit margins."
That view was echoed by
Public Knowledge, a Washington based public advocacy group.
"It's
a tough road ahead and the telcos are going to fight this to the
death," communications director Art Brodsky told BBC News.
"AT&T
in the first quarter of this year spent $6m on lobbying. That is one
company. One quarter. Compare that to Google which spent $4m in the
whole of last year."
The Computer and Communications Industry
Association said the "third way" option is the only realistic option.
"Without
deliberate FCC action, consumers, entrepreneurs, small businesses and
non-profits will be left completely powerless against the corporate
commercial interests of their unregulated internet access providers,"
said Ed Black, association president. SOURCE
Today's News Highlights 06.27.11
At Fort Campbell, mixed reviews for Afghan plan
Pfc. Rob Nunez, who spent eight months in Konar province near the Pakistani border, and some of his fellow soldiers have vastly different reactions to the plan.
(By Kevin Sieff)
Nancy Pelosi pursues her own ‘faith-based initiative’
House minority leader has her sights on winning back the speaker’s gavel for Democrats.
(By Karen Tumulty and Paul Kane)
Does GOP have a compromise on debt?
As President Obama prepares to meet with Senate leaders to try to restart talks over the debt, some Republicans see a potential path to compromise: Significant cuts in military spending.
(By Lori Montgomery and Paul Kane)
DNA links fugitive to professor’s slaying, FBI says
DNA evidence links a fugitive in Mexico to the killing of an American University professor, the FBI says.
(By Dan Morse)
A pair of veteran spies cross paths
Betty McIntosh and Doris Bohrer served in the OSS and CIA, but their remarkable friendship didn’t form until they moved to the same retirement community.
(By Ian Shapira)
POLITICS
President Barack Obama talks spending and debt limit with Senate leaders
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama takes over negotiations on spending cuts and raising the government’s borrowing limit when he holds separate meetings Monday with Senate leaders.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Supreme Court to rule Monday on Arizona law giving extra cash to publicly funded candidates
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is expected to rule Monday on an Arizona campaign finance law that gives extra cash to publicly funded candidates who face privately funded rivals and independent groups.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
AP IMPACT: Once-rural populations skyrocket near some US nuclear plants, evacuations unlikely
BUCHANAN, N.Y. — As America’s nuclear power plants have aged, the once-rural areas around them have become far more crowded and much more difficult to evacuate. Yet government and industry have paid little heed, even as plants are running at higher power and posing more danger in the event of an accident, an Associated Press investigation has found.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Supreme Court to rule Monday on California ban on sale, rental of violent video games to kids
WASHINGTON — Is it unconstitutional to ban the sale or rental of ultraviolent video games to children?
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Supreme Court to rule Monday on Arizona law giving extra cash to publicly funded candidates
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is expected to rule Monday on an Arizona campaign finance law that gives extra cash to publicly funded candidates who face privately funded rivals and independent groups.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
STYLE
Recession-wary performers turn Las Vegas Strip into parade of cartoon, movie characters
LAS VEGAS — The Las Vegas Strip is teeming with Spidermen, Elmos and Elvis Presleys of all waistlines.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Ask Amy: Husband ’fesses up to old affairs; wife is torn
Her husband confessed to indulging in two affairs years ago. She went to counseling with him and was told by the counselor to “get over it.” A) She’s not ready to and B) What kind of therapist is that?
(, Tribune Media Service)
Hints From Heloise: A unique wedding gift
Why not donate food left over from a wedding reception to a homeless shelter?
(, King)
Can sisters’ estrangement be avoided?
My religious-convert sister told my gay sister that she, her husband and children will not ever meet our gay sister’s 1-year-old twins.
(, The Washington Post)
Documentary presents case against tort reform
Susan Saladoff’s compellingly persuasive, no-nonsense documentary, “Hot Coffee,” explores the effects of the American war on “frivolous lawsuits.”
( by Hank Stuever , The Washington Post)
SPORTS
Sunday's Sports In Brief
LEON, Mexico — Two-time heart transplant recipient Erik Compton won the Mexico Open for his first Nationwide Tour title, closing with a 7-under 65 on Sunday for a two-stroke victory over Richard H. Lee.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Former Tar Heels star Jessica Breland recives Honda Inspiration Award at dinner
NEW YORK — Jessica Breland is always happy to share her story of overcoming Hodgkin’s lymphoma with the hope it can be helpful to someone else.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
PGA Tour: Travelers win is Jacobson’s first title
CROMWELL, Conn. — Fredrik Jacobson closed out his first PGA Tour title on Sunday, shooting a 4-under 66 in the Travelers Championship for a one-stroke victory over John Rollins and Ryan Moore.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Knee, hamstring injuries had Mitts fearing World Cup 'jinx' but she's with US in Germany
DRESDEN, Germany — When Heather Mitts felt that familiar pain in her hamstring during training last month, it was almost too much for the U.S. defender.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Tseng runs away with LPGA Championship
Top-ranked Yani Tseng wins the LPGA Championship by 10 strokes and, at 22, become the youngest player to win four LPGA Tour majors.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
WORLD
Malaysia says women must hold 30 percent of top corporate posts by 2016 for gender equality
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia — Malaysia’s government says women must hold 30 percent of top corporate posts by 2016 in a move toward gender equality in the boardroom.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Syrian opposition to meet in Damascus for first time since start of uprising
BEIRUT — Some 200 critics of President Bashar Assad’s regime are gathering in the Syrian capital for the first time since the start of the three-month uprising against his family’s rule.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
China says arrival of Sudanese president in Beijing for talks has been delayed
BEIJING — A planned visit by Sudan’s president to China, which was criticized by rights groups because he is wanted on international war crimes charges, was delayed Monday, though officials gave no reason.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao to strike trade deals worth $1.6 billion in UK talks
LONDON — Britain says the U.K. and China are sealing trade deals worth 1 billion pounds (US$1.6 billion) at a summit between national leaders.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Palestinians fan out across globe to seek support for recognition at UN
RAMALLAH, West Bank — Palestinian delegations will make the rounds of nearly a dozen countries to try to drum up more support for their bid to have the United Nations recognize a Palestinian state, senior officials said Monday.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
LIVE DISCUSSIONS
The Mil Life: Keeping spouses' careers, education off the chopping block
Military wives discuss keeping a career and educational goals through deployments.
(, vForum)
The Web Hostess: Online manners, memes and must-see video
A weekly chat about the best ways to kill time online. Our Web Hostess, Monica Hesse, sifts the Internet so you don't have to, searching for meaning, manners and the next great meme.
(, vForum)
Real Wheels Live
Live online discussion with Real Wheels columnist Warren Brown about car-buying and the auto industry.
(, vForum)
Lisa de Moraes on the TV Column
Post TV columnist Lisa de Moraes is back and ready to chat about all the drama, comedy and heartbreak of the world of television -- both onscreen and behind-the-scenes!
(, vForum)
Lisa de Moraes on the TV Column
Post TV columnist Lisa de Moraes is back and ready to chat about all the drama, comedy and heartbreak of the world of television -- both onscreen and behind-the-scenes!
(, vForum)
TECHNOLOGY
The Celebrity Moment
( by TechCrunch.com , TechCrunch.com)
Startups Don’t Die, They Commit Suicide
( by TechCrunch.com , TechCrunch.com)
Fanvibe Signs A Letter Of Intent To Be Acquired By beRecruited
( by TechCrunch.com , TechCrunch.com)
RunKeeper Adds New Integration To Its Health Graph In Hopes Of Building ‘The Facebook Of Fitness’
( by TechCrunch.com , TechCrunch.com)
World stock markets mixed on fears that Europe's debt crisis is about to get worse
BANGKOK — World markets were mixed Monday as Greece’s parliament began debating harsh new austerity measures that must pass for the country get its next batch of emergency financial aid.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
BUSINESS
Greek deputies to begin debate on crucial austerity plans before votes
ATHENS, Greece — Greek lawmakers begin debating new austerity plans Monday that must pass this week if the debt-ridden country is to receive the critical next installment of loans from its international bailout plan and avoid default.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
The Celebrity Moment
( by TechCrunch.com , TechCrunch.com)
Saab says $18.4 million car order from China could pay staff's wages
STOCKHOLM — Troubled car maker Saab Automobile AB has received a €13 million ($18.4 million) car order from a Chinese company that could help pay salaries to its employees, its owner Swedish Automobile AB said Monday.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Akzo Nobel, world's biggest paintmaker, warns 'adverse factors' will hurt Q2 earnings
AMSTERDAM — Akzo Nobel NV, the world’s largest maker of paint, warned Monday that second-quarter earnings will be hurt by commodity price rises, weak business in some regions and maintenance delays at some plants.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Oil falls to near $90 a barrel in Asia as US dollar gains amid Greek debt crisis
SINGAPORE — Oil prices fell to near $90 a barrel Monday in Asia as a stronger U.S. dollar made crude more expensive for investors with other currencies.
( Associated Press Associated Press , AP)
Posted at 11:31 AM in Anti-War Protests, ARTS AND ENTERTAINMENT, Civil Liberties, Commentary, Blog Feed Buzz, Commerce, Finance, Money Matters, Current Affairs, ECONOMIC WOES, Education, Entertainment News, HEALTH CARE ISSUES, Legal , Lifestyles, Looking Good, Fashion, TECHNOLOGY, TODAY'S PAPERS | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)
Technorati Tags: Today's News Highlights 06.27.11
| Reblog (0)