(10-26) 16:46 PDT OAKLAND -- To prosecutors, the trial of former BART police Officer Johannes Mehserle proved that he "abandoned all judgment and training and became part of a sweeping swell of officer aggression" when he killed unarmed train rider Oscar Grant.
To defense attorneys, jurors learned that Mehserle accidentally shot Grant while intending to subdue the 22-year-old with a Taser during a difficult arrest, making "a tragic and irreversible error while trying in good faith to do his job."
The interpretations were laid out Tuesday in legal briefs filed with Judge Robert Perry, who is scheduled to sentence Mehserle on Nov. 5 in Los Angeles County Superior Court.
Prosecutors are making a case for prison time for Mehserle, 28, who was convicted of involuntary manslaughter in July and has been jailed in Los Angeles ever since. The defense seeks his release on probation.
The court filings underlined a continuing disagreement at the heart of the case. Defense attorney Michael Rains said it was clear that jurors believed the New Year's Day 2009 shooting at the Fruitvale Station in Oakland was an accident when they rejected murder and voluntary manslaughter charges - both of which require prosecutors to prove an intent to kill.
However, Deputy District Attorney David Stein pointed to the jury's separate finding that Mehserle had intentionally used a gun. "While (the) defendant attempted to convince the jury that the shooting was an accident," Stein wrote, "the jury found otherwise."
Perry cannot call jurors back to court to question them on how they arrived at their verdict. None of the jurors has spoken publicly.
Mehserle faces five to 14 years in prison for involuntary manslaughter and the use of the gun. However, legal experts said, state law allows a judge to grant probation for involuntary manslaughter under unusual circumstances. And Rains argues that the gun-use enhancement should not apply to police officers, who carry weapons as part of their job.
In his filing, Stein said Mehserle deserved prison time because he had acted recklessly, taking advantage of a position of trust while killing a vulnerable victim. The use of the Taser defense, Stein wrote, undermined police-community relations.
Rains countered that Mehserle - a young man with an unblemished record - had decided to devote his life to protecting the public, only to lose his career and become the object of public scorn "in half a second, with no ill intention, and at least in part as the result of inadequate training and experience" at BART.
Comments Policy